What DSCR actually tells you
Debt service coverage ratio divides net operating income by annual debt service. At 1.25x, the property earns $1.25 for every dollar of mortgage payment. The 25 cents of cushion is what a lender underwrites against, because it absorbs a bad month before the loan goes into default.
This is the single number most likely to kill a multifamily deal in 2026. Agency debt prices near 5.30%, and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac size loans to a 1.25x minimum on stabilized assets. When your DSCR falls below the threshold, the lender does not decline outright. The lender shrinks the loan until the ratio works, and you fill the gap with equity you did not plan to spend.
Why DSCR is a proceeds constraint, not a pass or fail
Investors treat DSCR as a yes or no test. Lenders treat it as a sizing input. If your NOI supports only 1.18x at the loan amount you asked for, the lender re-solves for the loan amount that produces 1.25x. That gap comes out of your equity check, and it changes every downstream return.
Run the calculator twice. Once at the loan you want, once at the loan the lender will actually give you. The difference is the real equity requirement.
The mistakes that inflate DSCR on a broker package
- Proforma NOI instead of trailing NOI. Brokers quote DSCR against a stabilized projection. Lenders size against trailing twelve-month performance, often with a haircut.
- Understated vacancy. A 3% vacancy assumption in a submarket running 8% inflates NOI and the ratio with it.
- Missing capital reserves. Lenders deduct $250 to $300 per unit per year before calculating NOI. Broker packages frequently leave this out.
- Interest-only periods. DSCR during an IO period looks strong, then drops the moment amortization begins. Underwrite the amortizing payment.
What to check next
DSCR on its own hides two related risks. Debt yield tells you what the lender recovers if it takes the asset back, and break-even occupancy tells you how far physical occupancy falls before the property stops covering its own payment. A deal at 1.28x DSCR with 88% break-even occupancy is far more fragile than the ratio suggests.